Trick-or-treating used to be a novelty in South-West Sydney. These days the streets of Prestons, Edmondson Park, Gregory Hills and Middleton Grange fill up on 31 October, and a child can come home with a pillowcase of lollies that would have been unthinkable a decade ago. Our dentists see the results through November.

This article ranks the usual Halloween haul from most to least harmful for teeth, explains the one idea that matters more than the total amount of sugar, and gives a handful of practical rules so your kids can enjoy the night without a filling to show for it.

It is not how much sugar, it is how often and how long

Every time sugar reaches the bacteria in plaque, they produce acid for roughly the next half hour, and enamel loses mineral while the acid lasts. Saliva then needs time to neutralise the acid and repair the surface. Teeth cope well with occasional sugar followed by a long break. They cope badly with a steady trickle.

So a child who eats ten lollies in one sitting after dinner, then brushes, has given their teeth one acid episode. A child who eats the same ten lollies spread across a Saturday has given them ten. The total sugar is identical, but the damage is not. Duration matters too, because a sweet that dissolves slowly or sticks to the teeth keeps feeding bacteria long after it is “finished”.

Ranking the haul from worst to least bad

  1. Sticky caramels, toffees, fruit chews and gummies. They wedge into the grooves of back teeth and between teeth, where brushing struggles to reach, and keep releasing sugar for a long time.
  2. Sour lollies. These combine sugar with citric or malic acid, so the enamel is softened by acid at the same moment the bacteria are fed. Sour powders and sour straps are the worst of the group, and the acid alone can cause tooth erosion.
  3. Hard lollies and lollipops. Less sticky, but they sit in the mouth for minutes at a time, and children often crunch them, which can chip teeth.
  4. Plain chocolate. Chocolate melts and washes away quickly, so the sugar exposure is short. It is still sugar, but of everything in the bag it is the least damaging to teeth. Bars with caramel or toffee centres belong in the first group.

If that surprises you, our Easter chocolate article explains in more detail why chocolate gets off relatively lightly. The short version is that what sticks and what lingers does the damage.

Practical rules for Halloween week

You do not need to confiscate the bag. A few household rules do most of the work:

Younger children need a parent to brush for them or at least finish the job, because the back teeth where gummies lodge are exactly the teeth small hands miss.

What this looks like at Star Light Dental

Our Prestons clinic in Hoxton Park Central is a family practice, and Dr Liza Mekhael has a particular interest in children’s dentistry and in helping anxious young patients feel settled. A check-up in November is a sensible way to catch anything the Halloween haul has started while it is small, and to apply fluoride varnish to teeth that need it.

For eligible children, the Medicare Child Dental Benefits Schedule covers check-ups and a range of basic treatment, and we accept it along with all health funds and NSW Government dental vouchers. There is free on-site parking, and Saturday appointments from 10am to 3pm suit school-age families.

Frequently asked questions

Should I just ban Halloween lollies?

Most dentists would not. A ban tends to push sweets underground and turns them into something to sneak. Clear limits on when and for how long sweets are eaten protect teeth almost as well and are far easier to keep.

Are fruit straps and dried fruit better than lollies?

Not for teeth. Fruit straps, dried fruit and fruit leathers are sticky and high in sugar, so they behave like gummies in the mouth. Fresh fruit is a different story, because it is eaten quickly and contains water and fibre.

A lolly is stuck between my child’s teeth and will not come out. What should I do?

Try flossing it out gently or rinsing with water. Do not use anything sharp. If it will not shift, or the tooth becomes sore, book an appointment so we can remove it and check the tooth.

Book a children’s check-up in Prestons

If it has been a while since your child’s last visit, or the Halloween bag is still going strong, now is a good time. Learn about our children’s dentist in Prestons and what a check-up involves. Book online, call (02) 9432 2833 or email [email protected].

This article is general information only and is not a substitute for advice from your dentist.